Skip to main content

Experiencing the output of a brand’s intent

As it stands, our perception of a brand is made up from a lot of different experiences. How we feel based on interactions with different types of staff, retail spaces, ads, marketing campaigns, partnerships, packaging, website, logo. The list is long. However, an argument could be made that product sits at the top of that list as this is one of the main aspects that provide value to the customer. (Or not, depending on how good the products are).

We know that when we buy a Jaguar F Type, it was designed and manufactured by Jaguar. We know that when we buy a Dyson vacuum cleaner that we are experiencing what they themselves intended for us to experience. What it is, how it performs, how it looks, how it feels, how it’s packaged, etc. This post is more about a question I have rather than any sort of answer, and that is the following:

‘Imagine a brand controlled all aspects of their business other than product. They didn’t actually have input, intent or quality checks regarding product. In essence, it’s not THEIR product. But you did experience their marketing, website and other aspects that make up the brand. Would you feel more negatively about such a brand? Or not?’

Essentially, can product be disassociated from brand? Moreover, what is the impact of that and can it be a valid recipe for commercial success and strong brand perception? Now, selling products that aren’t yours obviously isn’t anything new. If you walk into Selfridges and leave with a Sage coffee machine, we understand that Selfridges were never pretending the coffee machine was theirs. With this model, the buying director at the retailer made an active choice to stock that product and carried out a process to assess the product’s quality.

 

can product disassociate from brand

 

Another example is OEM or white-label products bought by brands and sold under their name without developing the product from scratch. With this model, you could argue it’s not totally their original work but there’s still the intent and responsibility there. They made an active choice and still have control over what the product is that is being delivered.

 

Might new models lose grip on brand consistency?

With digital marketing and drop-shipping business models as they are, this relationship between product and brand could get a little more complex. And when I say complex, I mean complexity for the customer in their understanding of authenticity. The understanding of where and who the products they’re buying have come from.

I’d like to share an example of such a new model. YouTuber Mr. Beast (aka Jimmy Donaldson) just launched a nationwide fast food chain on Twitter. It’s basically the culinary equivalent of an Amazon drop-ship business and he’s stated that he’s ‘launched 300 restaurants’ (basically overnight).

Decentralised production isn’t new. Mr Beast is just one of the first to put this ‘ghost chain’ model in motion to build a ‘restaurant’ empire.

 

can product disassociate from brand

 

I’m sceptical on the quality and authenticity of this. I can see the potential that each of the 300 ‘production houses’ could be a restaurant in their own right and each could order their own beef, their own bread, use their own sauces, their own packaging, have their own culture of service, their own standards of training. I’m not saying this specific example will play out like this, but I do think the model in general has the potential when undertaken by others to go against a consistent brand experience and possible lower product quality. Deliveroo and UberEats are modern businesses, but they connect us with brands of different sizes who carry their full intent right into the product. It’s transparent. This celebrity ghost chain model feels a little different to me though and I’m interested if anyone else sees the negatives with regard to brand, product quality and authenticity?

I’ve got a feeling we’re going to see more celebrities releasing their own ‘restaurant chains’ overnight through this model. If this happens at scale and the possible negatives I’ve highlighted do play out – it just doesn’t feel great to me and loses authenticity. However, if product quality can be assured effectively as well as maintaining a unique brand experience consistently – it’s one hell of a commercial opportunity and pretty disruptive at that.

Any thoughts. Let me know in the comments.

Nick Chubb

Author Nick Chubb

More posts by Nick Chubb

Join the discussion One Comment

  • Dom says:

    Hi Nick,

    Great Article, on an interesting topic. I found myself thinking around lots of subjects not mentioned.

    My intial idea was that, entirely separating product from Brand would never be successful as the product in my opinion is the result or a representation of the companies brand and values and the proof is always in the pudding, with products not accurately representing the brand losing customer confidence. It feels a step to removed from the department store model or from marketing using media influencer’s.

    However this is on the assumption that successful ventures require long term customer relationships. Mr Beast and his burger could launch his 300 stores, sell 50 million burgers to each of his followers over the next few months, close the stores and disappear. The customers would be happy to have that connection with the online celebrity they admire and wouldnt notice the variation between restaurants and poor quality product.

    I am no fan of this hype-based model but optimism is keen to see where it takes us.

    Keep up the good content

Leave a Reply

four × 5 =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.