You may have seen a recent post by Boostfolio talking about donuts. Or rather, a ‘donut skill set’. The idea being that student and recent graduate designers can often focus heavily on tool-based skills such as 3D modelling, rendering and animation (representing the ring of the donut) – and the hole in the middle representing a core design skill-set that’s often missing. The core being the foundational skill of design THINKING.
The post states that focusing on these tools alone is not enough and I wholeheartedly agree.
Has the message ‘Process over Final Design’ been pushed too far or does it have the potential to be interpreted too extremely?
Over the years I’ve given many design talks at different Universities and one thing I push a lot is the fact that the portfolio should not look like a catalogue of your products. I often highlight a common portfolio mistake of page after page showing render after render. With the observation from reviewing thousands of folios that not enough process is being shown, it led to the healthy promotion of the message that there needs to be more of a focus on the process and how you got to the final solution – rather than only presenting the final design.
I know many experienced industrial designers who feel the same way and also know many who share and push this very same message. However, a few comments from student and graduate designers across a few platforms has led me to think this message has potentially been taken a little too far. I’m basing this on a few comments that fall somewhere along the lines of ‘Employers don’t care about the final design. It’s all about process’. This is where I felt the need to raise my hand.
Quality of thinking
In a recent live webinar for Design Truth I talked about two key things to be communicated in a design portfolio. One being the quality of communication and the other being the quality of thinking. The key point of this article is to highlight that I think the final design DOES matter immensely, because it’s a direct output of the quality of thinking.
If you’re interested in seeing that talk, you can take a look below:
Quality of thinking is not something that is only shown through process and development work. The final design is evidence of that level of thinking. Hence, the proof is in the pudding.
In my view, your ability to think things through in a robust way with regards to usability is questioned in the final design. I would actually argue that the final design is often the number one thing in the folio that leads to the questioning of someone’s thinking. More so than HOW they actually went about communicating that very same thinking. A glaring problem (if there is one) with regards to usability, technical feasibility or manufacturability is usually exposed quickly in the final design. Therefore, the final design is significant in the judgement of a candidate’s ability to think things through.
Doing a good job of communicating WHAT you thought is different to the QUALITY of your thoughts. The latter is evidenced in the final design. Therefore, thinking is not segregated from the final design and the final outcome does have huge importance. So, for anyone who may have interpreted the message ‘Process over Final Design’ in a polarising way – I’d say reconsider the immense importance of the quality of the final design and how it’s presented.
In conclusion, your shit hot renders that show the refinement of the final design ARE important. With the encouragement of seeing more process – let’s not be too polarising and forget that.
As usual, questions or comments welcome.
Cheers, Nick.


I was only able to read the blogpost, and not watch the video you reference, but it was engaging all the same.
The word that stood out while reading was “employers.” Using this word relegates the post to an economic/contractual perspective. It assumes that designers are ultimately at the mercy of their employers, or potential employers. In this perspective the blogpost, and the claims, make perfect sense. The employer does, in fact, care about a hot shit render because it will likely sell best. This perspective perpetuates the illusion that designers aren’t allowed teeth, and are without valid opinions beyond a final product image. I’d challenge this blogpost, and ask it to open itself up to other possibilities for what design and designers ultimately ‘get paid’ to do.
It’s true that employers care about the final design imagery (it’s what sells), but what if the designers decide they don’t place such a high priority on presentation of a design? Maybe the consensus among students and younger designers is that they don’t really care about the final design presentation, and maybe employers should follow suit… I’d support them trying to make changes in the industry. I agree that the final design matters, to employers and designers alike, but the final presentation of that design doesn’t compare in level of importance. The thing is, you CAN polish a turd when it comes to industrial design.
I don’t think that industrial designers have overcorrected, like the post claims. Rather I just think that the argument of, “process matters more than final design presentation,” has started to push up against an economic paradigm of what employers want, and that’s one reason you wrote this. I applaud the designers, students included, who are pushing a new narrative. A narrative that doesn’t rely on traditional design frameworks, often dictated by industry elite only.
On another note, I think it’s important to recognize that there are so many forms of communication available to a designer, and a hot shit render is only one of the many. Napkin-sketch ideas can communicate a brilliant idea, same with prototypes, 3d prints, crappy photoshop, or poorly lit renders.
Anyway, those are some of my thoughts. Thanks for writing the article and embracing discussion. Cheers.
Hi Hank. Thanks for reading the post and leaving a response. Based on what you’ve said I think your interpretation of the article is quite far from its intention. (I take partial responsibility for that.) However, I can’t help but feel you’ve substituted ‘final design’ for ‘final design presentation’ in your thinking (as well as using those words together in many instances) – leading to your comments about polishing turds, etc. The article is just a reminder on the importance of quality of final design within the context of a portfolio due to the fact that quality of thinking is evidenced in a final design. To clarify, quality of final design – not just the quality of presentation of that design. With regards to the use of the word ’employer’ – that was only used once as a quotation of somebody else saying ’employers don’t care about final design’ which I disagreed with. Hence the article. Thanks again for reading. Cheers, Nick.