I believe deeply in the value of design for business growth, elevating brand and making a positive contribution to people’s lives at scale. I love it. I take the impact of design seriously and have chosen a career with the responsibility of articulating its value to others and leading the process of its execution. Having said that, I sense there are some designers who can get on their high horse a bit and oversimplify the role of design in business. As in, making out that design is the centre of the Universe and nothing else factors into the equation of commercial success. An experienced chap I know would probably call them self-aggrandising.
The reality is that there are many factors contributing to the sales figures of a product. That complex web of inputs is extensive. Design is one. Another is distribution.
Assumption of good design
In several conversations in the last few months I’ve heard people from a variety of different businesses, industries and job roles speak positively about the design of certain products. These comments were not thoughts related to the specifics of the design though, and that’s the part that bothers me. The remarks seemed to be more along the lines of assumption that because these particular products had significant sales revenue then they almost without question represent design work that should be looked at in a positive light. More than that, almost automatically put on a pedestal. For no reason other than the sales revenue associated with that product. Where’s the independent point of view on the actual design?
I don’t believe commercial success translates to an automatic certification for good design – and I get the feeling it plays into people’s thoughts more than it potentially should when evaluating design. On a side note, I think prior knowledge of who has designed a product can also skew opinion rather than evaluating through pure focus on the product itself.
There are many brands with legacy distribution created by products from the past. With incredible distribution, mediocre or even poorly designed products can get launched and do well commercially in the short or mid term.
Thoughtful analysis: Because or Despite?
Products that didn’t do well commercially could still be looked at in a positive light if focusing on a particular aspect because their reasoning for commercial failure may come down to many other factors. Lack of sales doesn’t mean the product didn’t do a handful of things incredibly well.
So, next time you’re evaluating design – focus on the design and don’t narrow the field of vision only to those with leading sales figures. Projects can still benefit from analysis of ‘competitor’ products that didn’t take off in the market as well as they perhaps could have. It requires confidence as a designer and a strong point of view to go against the grain and point out specifically what you think doesn’t work well in a product that sells incredibly well and comes from a beloved brand. Equally, those traits as a designer of having an independent point of view come into play to see the merits and inspiration in unpopular or poor-selling products.
One thing I would add is that I’d potentially give more weight to commercial success and believe it’s a more positive reflection on the brand, their sales and marketing teams and the product itself if it has achieved great revenue as a start-up with no prior sales and distribution channels.
What’s an unpopular product you like or see merit in?
A product you love from a brand not seen as cool?
Or a product or service that didn’t work commercially but had other positive elements?
Product management teams can sometimes steer design projects towards whatever format or overall embodiment is executed by whoever is the leader (commercially) in that space. It’s our job when developing new breakthrough products for brands to identify that the established products in the market with leading sales figures may be performing well DESPITE some poor design choices – and not necessarily BECAUSE of them.
Cheers,
Nick

